Command Palette
Search for a command to run...
Preprint WatchStrongSeptember 24th, 2026
Spatial transcriptomics reveals epithelial-immune remodeling preceding malignant transformation of oral premalignant lesions
Jiang YJ, Ali I, Genkinger JM, King OD, Phillipone E, Momen-Heravi F.
Xenium spatial transcriptomics of HPV-negative oral premalignant lesions identifies TIGIT-high, exhaustion-associated T cells as part of a coordinated epithelial-immune program that precedes malignant transformation, with epithelial neighbourhoods depleted of dendritic cells and enriched for TIGIT-high T cells.
Strong contradiction
4 prior failuresThree or more documented clinical failures match this mechanism, or a Phase 3 efficacy failure is on record.
This preprint places TIGIT-high exhausted T cells inside the tissue program that precedes oral cancer, which is a descriptive finding about where the checkpoint sits, not evidence that blocking it changes outcomes. The Claidex graph holds four TIGIT programs and none of them supports the inferential step from presence to therapeutic benefit. Ociperlimab missed in first-line PD-L1-high non-small cell lung cancer (ociperlimab-tigit-advantig-302-nsclc-class-failure) and tiragolumab missed in the adjuvant setting of the same disease (tiragolumab-tigit-adjuvant-nsclc-phase3-class-efficacy-failure), both read at the time as class efficacy failures. Vibostolimab was pulled from BCG-unresponsive non-muscle-invasive bladder cancer (vibostolimab-favezelimab-tigit-bcg-unresponsive-nmibc-keynote-057-phase2-strategic-termination) and terminated in adjuvant melanoma on a safety signal (vibostolimab-pembrolizumab-tigit-adjuvant-melanoma-keyvibe-010-phase3-safety-termination). The pattern across those four is that TIGIT expression on exhausted T cells has repeatedly marked a state that antibody blockade did not usefully reverse. A premalignant setting is a genuinely different context and may behave differently, but any translational proposal arising from this work should state explicitly why interception before transformation escapes the mechanism that defeated four later-stage programs.
Matching Claidex post-mortems
4 of 4 indexed- May 19, 2026AdvanTIG-302: ociperlimab and the slow collapse of TIGIT in NSCLCOciperlimab (BGB-A1217)EfficacyMRS 41
- Jun 11, 2026Tiragolumab in resected NSCLC: an adjuvant trial closed by the class-wide TIGIT collapseTiragolumabEfficacyMRS 41
- Sep 7, 2026Merck ended KEYNOTE-057 for business reasons, and the TIGIT question in BCG-unresponsive bladder cancer went with itPembrolizumab/vibostolimab (MK-7684A) and favezelimab/pembrolizumab (MK-4280A) coformulationsSponsorMRS 72
- Sep 13, 2026Vibostolimab in adjuvant melanoma: toxicity ended the trial before the endpoint couldPembrolizumab/vibostolimab coformulation (MK-7684A)SafetyMRS 77
This is an automated contradiction flag, not an editorial judgment on the preprint's quality. Flags identify where the preclinical literature and the clinical failure record diverge.

