Command Palette

Search for a command to run...

Preprint WatchStrongOctober 30th, 2026

Targeting the sinusoidal-to-capillarized transition to normalize vessels in breast cancer liver metastasis

Huang, H.-Y.; Zhao, C.; Zheng, X.-N.; Shi, Y.-X.; Tian, L.

Targeting TNF signalling in metastasis-associated liver vessels dampens their inflammatory state but promotes metastatic outgrowth, so TNF blockade is presented as non-viable in this setting and the tip cell marker Esm1 is proposed instead.

Strong contradiction

3 prior failures

Three or more documented clinical failures match this mechanism, or a Phase 3 efficacy failure is on record.

A bioRxiv preprint on breast cancer liver metastasis reports that perturbing TNF signalling dampened the inflammatory state of metastasis-associated vessels but promoted metastatic outgrowth, concluding that TNF blockade is not a viable strategy in that setting and proposing the tip cell marker Esm1 instead. The claim corroborates rather than contradicts the Claidex record, which holds three TNF failures, all carrying the efficacy archetype: balinatunfib-sar441566-tnf-ulcerative-colitis-specifi-uc-phase2-interim-efficacy-termination, balinatunfib-sar441566-tnf-tnfr1-crohns-disease-phase2-program-termination and inb03-soluble-tnf-covid19-ards-futility. Severity is strong under the scoring rule because three prior failures on this target carry that archetype. The mechanism offered is specific and testable: suppressing inflammatory signalling can remove a brake rather than a driver, which is a failure mode distinct from insufficient target engagement and one that a target engagement biomarker would not detect.

Abstract excerpt

Liver metastases exhibit marked resistance to anti-VEGF anti-angiogenic therapies, yet the underlying mechanisms remain poorly understood. By combining single-cell RNA sequencing of human breast cancer liver metastases with a liver sinusoidal endothelial cell (LSEC) lineage-tracing mouse model, we show that liver metastasis-associated vessels originate from Lyve1+ sinusoidal endothelial cells but undergo a sinusoidal-to-capillarized transition as they grow into the metastatic nodule, characterized by enhanced inflammatory signaling, loss of sinusoidal markers, and acquisition of capillarized markers. We functionally perturbed each of these abnormalities individually. Unexpectedly, ectopic Lyve1 overexpression paradoxically enhanced hyaluronan and other extracellular matrix deposition in the tumor microenvironment, suggesting a compensatory mechanism. Similarly, targeting TNF signaling, a hallmark inflammatory pathway in liver metastasis, dampened the inflammatory state of metastasis-associated vessels but promoted metastatic outgrowth, indicating that TNF blockade is not a viable strategy for metastasis treatment. Strikingly, inhibition of the capillary tip cell marker Esm1 improved vessel perfusion and enhanced chemotherapeutic drug delivery, two defining features of vascular normalization. Pan-cancer analysis further revealed that Esm1 expression is restricted to tip cells and correlates with poor patient prognosis, positioning Esm1 as a candidate target for promoting vascular normalization. Collectively, our findings reveal the vascular plasticity of liver metastasis and, although not all abnormal features are actionable, we propose targeting Esm1 to inhibit sprouting angiogenesis and to normalize dysfunctional liver metastasis vessels, offering a promising therapeutic avenue for liver malignancies.

Matching Claidex post-mortems

3 of 3 indexed

This is an automated contradiction flag, not an editorial judgment on the preprint's quality. Flags identify where the preclinical literature and the clinical failure record diverge.